Dear Ms. Thunberg,
 
I am writing to you because of the discussions and incidents that happened this week around the vote of the European Parliament on the Nature Restoration Law. I think it's essential to respect each other and to take citizens along when we try to address the dramatic climate crisis that we are in. I very much regret that we couldn't meet personally this week. I was prepared for the meeting with Manfred Weber and some of your fellow activists on Tuesday, but you couldn't make it for reasons I still don't know. I would be grateful if you and your team could clarify this.
 
I very much admire your engagement and the movement that you triggered around the world. I'm convinced that, especially in the European Union, this dedication, and the movement dramatically changed politics and the economy. For two or three years, I only met representatives of enterprises concretely planning for decarbonization. The adoption of the biggest climate law ever in the European Union, the ETS, which I steered as a rapporteur, was only possible with your strong commitment. However, I very much regret the gesture you showed after adopting the much-changed nature restoration law in the European Parliament. To show people the middle finger is never creating something positive. While politicians are used to such things, for me, it is essential to point out that not only politicians but also farmers didn't support the nature restoration law. I spoke to forest owners that were concerned that the law would stop them from planting trees adapted to climate change. Unfortunately, we don't have the climate of 70 years ago. That's why we cannot refer any activity in forestry to the situation of 70 years ago. We need to plant trees that might not be native to Europe but still can cope better with the changed climate. I am firmly convinced that sustainable forestry is one of the primary keys to addressing climate change. Among the opponents of the law were also the operators of hydropower plants. They saw the law, particularly Article 7, as an obstacle to their activity when we desperately need more renewable energy. In the country I know best, Germany, also many representatives from municipalities, including their official association (Städte- & Gemeindebund) criticized the law. Even the Green Prime Minister of Baden Württemberg raised serious concerns. They all may feel insulted by your gesture. That's why I think it would be appropriate to apologize not only to the MEPs but also to all who feel represented by them. To succeed in our climate mitigation policy, we must take people along. As you may have realized during the last four years, the fight against climate change is not a sprint but a marathon. To run a marathon, you also need supporters that give you water along the way, which means that society should understand what we are doing and should not feel provoked.
 
Dear Ms. Thunberg, I am convinced that climate change is the biggest challenge for our political generation, and that's why I worked so hard to manoeuvre an even more ambitious ETS through the European institutions. An article in EURACTIV describes my role here (https://www.euractiv.com/section/climate-environment/opinion/the-brief-chapeau-mr-liese/). Unfortunately, the very important ETS2 has been criticized and challenged not only by the far right but also by the Greens, the Left, and the Socialists in the European Parliament. It took me a lot of effort to get the majority in Parliament, and unfortunately, I had to weaken the level of ambition. We postponed the introduction by one year and included an emergency break for another year. Moreover, we had to include a price cap although you and your fellow campaigners insist on much higher CO2 prices. Unfortunately, I am not aware of any criticism from your side or your fellow campaigner's side against the Greens, the Left, or the Social Democrats in this regard. This is very disappointing for me in particular because I had the opportunity to speak with Luisa Neubauer about this and I provided her with a lot of information.
 
Dear Ms. Thunberg, I still admire your commitment and I strongly encourage you to continue your work, but I also encourage you to show more respect and to look at the issue from a non-party political point of view. Unfortunately, I had the feeling that in the case of ETS2, you and your fellow campaigners didn't act because it was the Greens that had to be criticized. I am firmly convinced that we can only be successful if we respect each other and if we also manage to convince the centre of the political spectrum, in Europe the EPP, which is the biggest political group. However, with this kind of gestures, you will definitely not be successful.                      
 
I am eager to get an answer to my letter, and I am always ready to talk to you.                            
 
Best regards                                                                                                                                                        
 
Peter Liese
Member of the European Parliament

Amendments to delete ETS 2 by Greens, ID and ECR